The Sacred Willow: Four Generations in the Life of a Vietnamese Family
Come across a Problem?
Thanks for telling us most the problem.
Friend Reviews
Community Reviews
Information technology's a lot to pack into 475 pages, and the author balances the story of her family with a broader historical perspective. The history appears well-researched, and based on her bibliography, draws heavily on Vietnamese equally well as English-language sources. It also seems counterbalanced; at times, when family members' paths during the war diverge sharply, nosotros go separate capacity covering the same events from unlike perspectives, and the writer doesn't seem to be advocating for either one over the other. Though the author's parents threw in their lot with the French and later on South Vietnam, she – like many Vietnamese – seems to respect the communists' commitment, and while the American intervention was a short-term benefaction for middle-class families like hers, she ultimately seems to conclude that the communist victory was both inevitable and not as awful equally propaganda had led the South Vietnamese to expect.
The book'southward biggest weakness is that it is rather dry, much more focused on facts than building a dramatic narrative. Though it is in part a memoir, we learn little about the author herself; she tends to relate the facts of a state of affairs with perchance a bald statement of her feelings, only without developing any of the emotional particular that might allow readers to experience the story along with her. There are exceptions, though; her account of the dramatic last days before the fall of Saigon (through the eyes of several family unit members) is downright gripping.
Overall, I'd recommend this volume, but more for educational purposes than entertainment. It is a potent answer to the residual of English language-language literature about Vietnam, which tends to be from an American perspective and focused exclusively on the war.
...moreETA: After reading this book you lot must read about the Tranquillity War in Laos and the Hmong who fought information technology: The Spirit Catches You lot and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures
Do you really want to understand the Vietnam State of war? This book is about a Vietnamese family that lived through it. What is special about this book is that the author saw all sides of the war. In her ain family some were on the side of the Viet Minh and others supported the Fre
On completion:ETA: Afterwards reading this volume you must read virtually the Quiet War in Laos and the Hmong who fought it: The Spirit Catches You and Yous Fall Downwardly: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Standoff of Two Cultures
Practice you really want to understand the Vietnam War? This volume is about a Vietnamese family unit that lived through it. What is special most this volume is that the author saw all sides of the war. In her ain family some were on the side of the Viet Minh and others supported the French and and then the Americans. Never did whatsoever of the family stop being family unit to each other. The writer was in fact educated in the Us, married an American and worked for the Rand Corporation, employed to written report the motives of the Viet Minh. Through this book you learn of all parts of the war. All sides are fairly represented and rather than being observed, lived. There is much history documented, so the volume is not for those who want a quick read. After reading this volume I have a much better agreement of the state of war. As I stated below it starts with life of the author(s great grandfather, a Mandarin scholar. It continues up through the 1990s. All aspects, personal, political and historical are covered. Thoroughly. Definitely worth four stars.
Through folio 182:
The get-go chapter is the hardest to get through. Don't be deterred. This is an splendid book. You follow four generations of a Vietnamese family unit, the author'south own family. The reader is introduced to the ancient beliefs of the mandarins. Now the appointment is 1949 and some of the family unit accept joined the Viet Minh. Others back up the French colonialists. Y'all start by learning of aboriginal beliefs and customs. Y'all acquire of Vietnam history from the 1800s on. Y'all encounter how this family lived through the events listed in history books. You become more from this book than you will ever become from a history book since not only practice you get the historical and political details but likewise how these events played out in one family. You are shown a consummate life - daily practices, nutrient, housing, customs, religious beliefs and the political and historical events too. This isn't fiction; information technology is the real thing.
Personally, I side with the Viet Minh. Peradventure the author is biasedd; I do not care. I am being given her point of view. I am in the countryside with the Viet Minh. I am learning how they reasoned, what they ate, where they slept. I am living their life with them. The author's male parent worked for the French. I have lived with him too and followed how he thought and reasoned too. I sympathise both sides now.
Read this book if you want to really larn most Vietnamese history and culture.
In that location is a simple family chart at the get-go, good maps and an alphabetize if you need to search after something y'all take forgotten. And there is a bibliography.
...more thanI was impressed with Elliott's lucidity throughout the account and by her ability to acknowledge the different sides of the story, despite her obvious perspective as a "middle grade" Vietnamese. (I am not an expert with regards to Vietnamese demographics during the 20th century however I would guess that what she describes as "middle class" was actually a minority of the territory'southward residents. Elevation x% perhaps would be a more authentic style to describe their socio-economic status.)
This quote from chapter fifteen which describes the American's withdrawal and subsequent autumn of South Vietnam to Communist hands, struck me as particularly honest: "At that moment, the anti-communists appeared for what they were: a conglomeration of tightly knit families motivated solely by a hatred and fear of communism and held together only by the glue of American ability. When that glue dissolved, the group disintegrated into its individual parts - families now concerned with saving themselves. They had never had a larger vision of what S Vietnam should be or why one should fight for information technology. My relatives were no unlike."
As noted by some other Goodreaders, the book is a little long, and at times disruptive, simply I cannot imagine another way to do justice to the deep history interwoven with the lives of the Duong family. Elliott has a solid grasp of celebrated facts across the experiences of her relatives and does a masterful job of making a difficult and complex era accessible to the 21st-century reader. Impressive.
...moreI enjoyed the book and was never bored with it, but became somewhat frustrated with information technology towards the terminate when she described the fall of Saigon to the Viet Cong. My frustration stemmed from the fact that I found this section of the volume utt
This is the story of iv generations of the writer'southward Vietnamese family but, allow's be straight about this, what'southward interesting virtually it to well-nigh people is the Vietnam State of war. I would never have picked upward a similar book about, say, 4 generations of a Burmese family.I enjoyed the book and was never bored with it, merely became somewhat frustrated with it towards the finish when she described the fall of Saigon to the Viet Cong. My frustration stemmed from the fact that I found this department of the book utterly gripping, deserving of five stars and quite the best description I've e'er read nigh what happened in those final few days and hours.
What this department fabricated me feel almost the book was that she'd made a error by going into the level of particular she did about the earlier generations of her family. Whilst those elements were interesting (though not riveting) in their ain correct and useful in putting into their historical context the growth of the Viet Minh, the expulsion of the French, the growth of the Viet Cong and the war against the United states of america, they didn't warrant the quantity of writing inside the book that she gave them. They were simply her personal family history, and writing about them in such item and at such length bordered on the self-indulgent, particularly in contrast to what came afterwards in the book.
Those earlier sections also suffered from their altitude, with the stories being told 3rd or 4th hand, as opposed to the mail service WWII elements which were generally told to her offset hand. I besides feel that she would accept done better allowing the people within the book to tell their stories in their own voices in the style of someone like Svetlana Alexievich than, every bit she did about people whom she clearly interviewed, "Giu felt lamentable to hear....".
A practiced book, though frustrating in that she had enough cloth to have written a great one had she been more ruthless in what she chose to go out out, what she chose to focus on and the manner some of the textile was presented.
...more thanIv stars considering the commencement couple generations are rather slow going, but it picks up with the story of the later generations. The fall of Saigon is as much a page turn
The four generations are the author's own family and is the story of Vietnam's fight for independence. It'south a fascinating tale, with members of the family on both sides of the war. It'due south very counterbalanced and comes through is that while they differed dramatically in the realm of politics, they connected to dear and respect each other.Four stars considering the showtime couple generations are rather slow going, but it picks upward with the story of the afterwards generations. The autumn of Saigon is as much a page turner as any bestselling mystery novel.
This book, forth with my visit to Hoa Lo prison house (aka Hanoi Hilton), gave me a very dissimilar perspective on the Vietnam War and Ho Chi Minh. From the Vietnamese perspective, they are analogous to our ain Revolutionary War and George Washington.
I look forrad to reading other books by this author.
...moreShe tells their history and experiences well and with sympathy and gives us a taste of the Vietnamese culture.
Thanks, Ms. Elliott, for this volume.
...more
It has been half dozen years since I went to Vietnam to build a business firm with Habitat for Humanity. Vietnam is not a country that I had planned to visit, only the opportunity presented "As my plane took off one fall morning from Hanoi. I looked out of my window and felt a sense of peace and closure. …I had seen Vietnam, the land of two one thousand thousand war dead, become again the country of the living. And I was taking back with me not the deafening explosions of weapons, but the gentle sound of the monsoon rain."
Information technology has been six years since I went to Vietnam to build a business firm with Habitat for Humanity. Vietnam is not a country that I had planned to visit, just the opportunity presented itself and then I went. I am glad I did. I learned a lot including that there are places hotter than Virginia in Baronial. I also met some wonderful people and ate some incredible food.
Since that trip I have connected to read and learn near the country, the people and the war that caused such disruption in Vietnam and the United States.
This book was a adept addition to my reading listing. Elliott tells the story of her family in the context of the French occupation, the carve up into two countries, the involvement with the United States and then the end of the state of war between North and Southward. She had a lot to comprehend which explains why her memoir is almost 500 pages. I now accept a much improve agreement of how the Vietnamese came to be warring confronting themselves. I will demand to sentry the Ken Burns documentary on Vietnam to help me understand how the U.s.a. got and so involved.
This was a very scholarly work about a family who took government service seriously. I wonder how this story would be told by someone whose family was middle or working class. I think Elliott has many advantages because of her family unit's service to the state. However, I realize that once Communism won the war, her family unit suffered because they weren't office of the proletariat.
The whole time I was reading this volume a particular song kept repeating in my head. Information technology is part of the reason that my quotation above is from the final paragraph of the book. Scott Ainsley is a wonderful vocalizer and this is his composition. https://www.youtube.com/sentinel?v=BT9Ps... I am glad there is peace again in Vietnam.
...more than"Those who cannot call back history are condemned to repeat it." Philosopher George Santayana Mae Elliot writes intelligently. A recollection of history which I remember strongly. In war cypher is pleasant. An nigh forgotten history of French colony, Cochin Prc and presently Vietnam is embroiled in a territorial dispute with China over the Spratly and Paracel islands in the South Communist china Sea.
"Those who cannot call up history are condemned to echo information technology." Philosopher George Santayana Mae Elliot writes intelligently. ...more than
I found this volume objective, providing historical groundwork and viewpoints from different angles. Swell read. Recommend to anyone who is interested in knowing about the defining history of Vietnam in 20th century
In the years post-obit her movement to the United States with her husband, she made several trips to Vietnam. Her most recent visits included trips as a guest lecturer for an Asia Society tour in February 2000, as a fellow member of a private Vietnamese-American delegation vetted by the White House for President Clinton'due south visit to Vietnam in November 2000, and equally a guest lecturer for Smithsonian study tours in February 2001 and March 2002.
After a long career in corporate cyberbanking, she resigned her job to write her family story, The Sacred Willow: Four Generations in the Life of a Vietnamese Family, which was published by Oxford University Press in April 1999 (nether the name of Duong Van Mai Elliott). The Sacred Willow was nominated for a Pulitzer Prize and was a finalist for the Asian-American literary award in the year 2000.
(from http://vi.uh.edu/vnwomen/maielliott.htm)
...moreNews & Interviews
Welcome back. Just a moment while we sign you lot in to your Goodreads account.
Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/62246.The_Sacred_Willow
0 Response to "The Sacred Willow: Four Generations in the Life of a Vietnamese Family"
Post a Comment